The purpose of this post is to hopefully help explain why your DNA and the genealogical paper trail sometimes, or in my case most of the time, don’t add up.
A very common complaint that I get is that people tell me:
“DNA lies, It says I am related to so and so as third cousins but on paper we are 7th cousins.”
I then ask them as to how many other ways are they related to that person. More-often their response is “several ways”.
Here lies the problem. In many cases our families intermarried within the close nit community for several reasons and for many generations.
For example, my ancestors settled in El Nuevo Reino de Leon, now days Monterrey Nuevo Leon Mexico. They were among the first settlers and guess what? There were only 10 families!
As you can imagine the reason for intermarrying within the group for the first few generations can well be concluded that they did it because of the scarcity of suitors and the distance between the other scarcely established towns.
Below are some pictures to help me illustrate what I am talking about. I apologize for the small sizes but that is the best that I could do.
The Perfect Family Tree
The Image below is how everyone imagines what their family tree looks like.
My Family’s Intermarrying
The following image is how my tree really looks like.
Remember the settling of Monterrey?
The concentration of lines on my tree are from the 1600 to the 1650’s and then from the 1750’s to the late 1750’s.
On the above image we can also see the intermarrying was less during the 1650’s until the 1750’s. This was probably due to the increase in population of the area and new arrivals adding to it.
Then in the 1750’s to the 1800’s we see heavy intermarrying once again. You know why?
My ancestors moved north to help the Spanish government colonize northern Mexico. They ended up in Revilla, Mier, and Carmargo and once again the suitors for marriage drastically decreased. Many argue that families did this to keep land within their own families but I do not think that to be the case. Thus we see the heavy intermarrying once again.
Now let’s break my tree down by each of my grandparents to see the intermarrying within their particular branches.
My Grandfather Eulalio Garza’s Tree
On my grandfathers side you can see the same intermarrying periods.
My Paternal Grandmother’s Dominga Marroquin Tree
For my grandmother you can only see a high number of intermarrying during the 1550’s through the 1650’s. The reason that they don’t have any intermarrying during the 1750’s is because they are late 1800 arrivals to northern Tamaulipas. So far the matches that I have had wiht other people through the Marroquin side the DNA matches accurately with the paper trail.
My Maternal Grandfather Juan Tanguma’s Tree
I was surprised to find that there was no intermarrying in his family tree. But again I have only traced his family back to the 1750’s but even like that you don’t see any intermarrying. Another reason might be that half of his ancestors are late arrivals to the area and were originally form the Zacatecas area. DNA matches on my Tanguma line are very accurate and match the papertrail.
My Maternal Josefina Lopez’s Tree
Just as my paternal grandmother you can only see a high number of intermarrying during the 1550’s through the 1650’s. You can also see more intermarrying during the 1750’s when northern Tamaulipas was settled.
My Son Matthew Garza’s Tree
When I ran my sons’s family tree which includes my tree and my wife’s tree you can see the high level of intermarrying that happened between both families.
Besides my Marroquin and Tanguma side DNA matches everyone else I match them more closely on DNA than what is shown int he paper trail.
I believe this to be due to the high level of intermarrying that we have in Northern Mexico and South Texas.
An example that me and my wife have is that of our 7th and a half great grandmother. We descend form her over 20 different ways. We also show two other sets of great grandparents that so far, we descend one way form them. DNA wise we are 3.5 Generations apart but on the paper trail it shows 7th cousins.
See Your Family’s Endogamy With This Tool
If you want to see or generate similar charts as the above one with your family tree this is the website that I used.
Hint: Use Internet explorer since the tool does not work on chrome or firefox.
Be on the look out for next weeks post. I will show you how to use this great tool.